Criticism of the pony carousel: animal cruelty or popular tradition?

Criticism of the pony carousel: animal cruelty or popular tradition?

At this year's Oktoberfest in Kaiserslautern, the pony carousel became the focus of criticism. Animal rights activists and concerned citizens accuse the operators of exploiting the animals. Reports of numerous letters to the local branch of the Left support the allegations that are now making the rounds in public. However, the operators of the carousel defend themselves against these accusations and emphasize that the animals are treated well.

Similar discussions were also initiated at the traditional stubble market in Vechta, which will take place from August 14th to 19th, 2025. Peta and other animal protection organizations also criticize the pony carousels there as a “nightmare for horses”. They warn that the ponies do not get enough rest in high temperatures and the health consequences for the animals can be serious. Joint and vertebral damage are being discussed, which is further fueling the debate.

An unexpected intervention

Peter Höffken from Peta makes no secret of his opinion and describes the situation as irresponsible. He sees the need to bring about change and calls for strict regulations for such attractions. Many official veterinarians also agree with these demands. In Vechta, the new Federal Animal Welfare Commissioner Silvia Breher, who is also the deputy federal chairwoman of the CDU, will open the festival. It remains to be seen whether she will address the critical voices in her speech.

The legal situation could be important here. The Federal Ministry of Agriculture has made it clear that a ban on pony carousels is not firmly anchored in the Animal Protection Act, but that they are subject to strict legal regulations. This information is in stark contrast to the current allegations and the sharp criticism that is being voiced in both Kaiserslautern and Lower Saxony, where around 800,000 visitors flock to the Stoppelmarkt every year.

Concerns about the welfare of the animals also bring Breher's appointment as animal protection officer into criticism. Peta sees this as a conflict, particularly given her previous role as managing director of an agricultural association. Criticism and doubts about their integrity are inevitable, as many get the impression that a slaughterer has been appointed animal protection officer here.

The discussion about the animal welfare situation at folk festivals is therefore in full swing, and the question remains whether the responsible authorities will finally take the necessary steps to ensure the welfare of the animals. While the pony carousel operators defend themselves and claim to be doing everything right, public opinion remains divided and views remain radical. Animal welfare organizations and concerned citizens will continue to raise their voices to keep the issue in sight.